High Demand, Low Supply: Health Centers and the Recruitment of Family Physicians

One Pagers | Jul 11, 2018 Caitlin Crowley, MPH; Michelle Proser, PhD, MPP; and Andrew Bazemore, MD, MPH

Expansion of the Health Centers Program has been associated with persistent workforce challenges for this critical component of the primary care safety net. In a national survey, 69% of health centers had a family physician (FP) vacancy. Those with FP vacancies reported spending an average of 11.4 months recruiting for an FP, one of the longest recruiting periods for a clinical position

After years of bipartisan support for expansion, the Health Centers Program collectively delivers care to more than 27 million patients in more than 10,000 predominately low-income communities—substantial growth from the 10 million served in 2000.1 A 2006 health center survey revealed that 13.3% of FP positions were vacant, which was third highest among physician positions and fourth overall.2 More than a decade later, the National Association of Community Health Centers resurveyed health centers on their clinical workforce vacancies and their recruitment and retention experiences. Of the 1,278 health centers surveyed, 499 (39%) responded. Respondents were representative of health centers nationally based on characteristics such as size, patient insurance mix, and geography.3

Results of this assessment show that clinical vacancies are still common at health centers—95% report having at least one. Vacancies for FPs are the most common, with at least one at 69% of the health centers (Figure 1).3 In addition, 51% of health centers indicate that filling an FP vacancy is their highest priority. Two-thirds of centers rate FP vacancies as very difficult to fill, and those with FP vacancies spend an average of 11.4 months recruiting for FPs, one of the longest periods reported for any clinical vacancy.3

Although health centers employ a multidisciplinary health professional workforce to meet the diverse needs of their patients, nearly one-half (46%) of all health center physicians are FPs,4 and survey findings suggest that FP supply is not meeting demand. This highlights a need for policy makers to support federal programs that create incentives and provide community-based primary care training opportunities for medical students and residents to ensure an adequate supply of FPs to staff health centers and provide care to underserved populations.

[Print]

Top 10 clinical vacancies reported by health centers. LCSW = licensed clinical social worker; LPN = licensed practical nurse; LVN = licensed vocational nurse. Other: psychiatrist (18%), dental hygienist (16%), other licensed mental health/substance abuse staff (16%), physician assistant (16%), psychologist (9%), nonlicensed mental health/substance abuse staff (8%), pharmacist (7%), certified nurse midwife (6%), vision services staff (6%). Information from reference 3.

References

1. NACHC, 2017. Includes patients of federally-funded and non-federally funded health centers, and expected patient growth for 2017. Bureau of Primary Health Care, HRSA, DHHS. 2000 and 2016 Uniform Data Systems. 

2. Rosenblatt RA, et al. Shortages of medical personnel at community health centers. JAMA. 2006;​295(9):​1042-1049.

3. National Association of Community Health Centers. Staffing the safety net:​ building the primary care workforce at America’s health centers. March 2016. http://​bit.ly/nachcworkforce. Accessed September 1, 2017.

4. Bureau of Primary Health Care, HRSA, DHHS. 2016 Uniform Data System.

The information and opinions contained in research from the Graham Center do not necessarily reflect the views or the policy of the AAFP.

Published in American Family Physician, August 1, 2018. Am Fam Physician. 2018;98(3):146. This series is coordinated by Kenny Lin, MD, MPH, Deputy Editor for AFP.